(800) 784-5194

Direct mail marketing is one of the most effective ways to generate leads, especially for mortgage brokers. And we can say that with confidence here at OverflowWorks.com as it is with building direct mail marketing campaigns for mortgage companies is where we got our start. 

We’ve worked with countless mortgage brokers over the years and we’ve seen what this marketing strategy can bring to the table. One of our clients even enjoyed a 41% increase in response and, from that, an additional 26% in conversions.

According to USPS, about 98% of consumers bring in their mail the day it’s delivered. Of these, about 72% bring it in as soon as possible. And 77% of them sort through their mail immediately. In spite of the increased use of smart devices, there’s a growing appreciation for receiving ‘something tangible’ like direct mail especially among millennials who are primarily the dominant target audience of the mortgage market alongside baby boomers.


How to Create Winning Mortgage Direct Mail Marketing Campaigns

If you want to achieve the best result for your direct mail marketing campaign, you have to pay attention to your mail’s content. Mail you send out should be top-notch, personalized, concise, and visually appealing to help you generate valuable leads. 

Here are 3 helpful tips that will help you get the best from your direct mail strategy to generate mortgage leads:


Segment Your List and Create Personalized Mail

First thing’s first, make sure you properly segment your list into demographic or behavioral categories whichever data is available. Segmenting your mailing lists paves the way for specific targeting and helps you create personalized messaging which increases engagement, maximizes conversions, and increases returns.

Personalization is crucial for getting your mail pieces noticed by your recipients and have them engaged. A recent survey reveals that 87% of consumers claimed that relevant branded content positively influences how they perceive the brand.

Learn how you can personalize your direct mails here: Personalization vs Individualization.


Make Your Offer Irresistible

Your ability to generate mortgage leads out of direct mail marketing depends on the attractiveness of your offer. In fact, your offer alone can carry your campaign to success. Wear your thinking cap, get creative, and make sure you create an offer that would be hard to resist.

Here’s what you should keep in mind when creating an offer:

  • The outcome should be clear. If you want your prospects to provide you with their personal data, or purchase something from you, you have to give them something in return. It could be a discount, free content, or any offer that you feel provides value to your audience.
  • Define a specific pain point you provide solutions for. Connect your offer to a specific problem your target audience is currently facing. The better you can make an emotional connection, the more irresistible your offer becomes.
  • Include social proof like testimonials and customer reviews. Showing evidence of how your products or services have helped other customers can definitely help your prospect in their decision-making.
  • Make a guarantee. Whether it’s as simple as providing phone consultation or providing money-back options, guarantees are important for your audience.

Remember though, what offer is irresistible can differ according to your segment. Take time to craft your messaging and research on what language speaks best to your audience can help you improve your offering.


Call to Action Should Be Clear

You may have the best, creative content but without a clear call-to-action, all of your efforts go to waste. Make it clear to your audience where they will be going and what they can expect from taking action. 

Here are some tips in writing your call-to-action:

  • Create a sense of urgency. This will induce a fear of missing out on a limited offer and provide incentives to your recipient so they get encouraged to take action. 
  • Highlight the benefits. What’s in it for your recipient? Give them a good reason why they should take action and provide them with something valuable.
  • Personalize the CTA. Even the simple gesture of adding your recipient’s name in the call-to-action is an underutilized and effective way to increase your conversions.
  • Remove friction. Determine where your audience is in the buying process and give them as easy a commitment as possible. Do not ask for a high commitment upfront especially if they’re a cold audience.
  • Use effective command words. Again, you want to be precise and clear with what you want your recipient to do. Use words like “shop”, “order”, “buy”, “subscribe”, “download”, etc.


For the best return for your budget, work with professional mortgage direct mail marketing experts, such as OverflowWorks.com. We use top-notch tools and create highly targeted campaigns for the right audience. We offer the best performance metrics possible to greatly improve the predictability of your marketing efforts.